EarthBorn Holistic Review

Earthborn Holistic is made by Midwestern Pet Foods, a family-run company that’s been around since 1926. It all started with a small milling operation in Indiana and four generations later, they’re still keeping it in the family. What makes Earthborn stand out? They cook all their dry food and treats in their own “kitchens”. No outside factories involved. Everything is made in the U.S., with facilities in Indiana, Illinois, New York, and Oklahoma. That gives them full control over quality and safety.

So, does Earthborn Holistic live up to the promise? Let’s take a closer look at a few of their top recipes and see what’s working… and what’s not.

PROS
  • Taurine is included due to its known role in supporting cardiac function, especially in diets low in animal protein.
  • Probiotics
  • No Artificial Ingredients or Common Allergens
  • Above AAFCO minimum
  • Reasonable Price Point
  • Good fresh meat content in most recipes
  • Solid omega-3 levels
CONS
  • Plant-Based Proteins: Estimated 40-60% of protein content may come from plant-based sources in some formulas.
  • Moderate to High carbohydrate content: many formulas contain 38-42% carbohydrates
  • Moderate to low protein levels : active dogs especially need higher protein levels
  • Not Human-Grade Meat: Ingredients not explicitly labeled as human-grade.
  • Incomplete Nutritional Information: Ash, calcium, and phosphorus content not provided
⚠️ Important : The Sheriff Score is our team's evaluation currently based on 27 criteria to help guide pet owners in choosing quality pet food. While it's a subjective assessment and not official or scientific advice, it offers valuable insights. We recommend consulting a veterinarian for advice tailored to your pet's specific needs.

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Unrefined Roasted Rabbit Recipe (Ancient Grains)

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Unrefined Roasted Rabbit Recipe - Sheriff Score
Sheriff Score D+
Nutrients and value
Protein content: 🟠 24%
Fat content: 🟢 15%
Ash content: Unknown
Fiber content: 🟠 8%
Moisture content: 🟢 10%
Calcium content: Unknown
Phosphorus content: Unknown
Metabolizable energy: 3600 kcal/kg
Omega-3 content: 1%
Omega-6 content: 3.5%
Carbohydrate content: 🟠 33%
Protein-to-calorie ratio: 67
Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio: Unknown
Animal protein content: 🟠 40-60%
High glycemic index ingredients: 🟢 None
Corn/wheat/soy content: 🟢 No
Chelated minerals: 🟠 Mix

Fresh rabbit sounds impressive until you realize what happens during processing. Heat and pressure strip away most of that moisture, leaving far less actual rabbit than the label suggests. The ancient grains aren’t necessarily bad – dogs have evolved some ability to handle starches unlike their wolf ancestors. But 33% carbohydrates? It’s still acceptable here. The probiotics are a nice touch, assuming they survive the manufacturing process.

Did you know ? Your dog's mouth can't break down starches like yours can⁴. They've got much less amylase enzyme, which is why properly processed grains matter more than you'd think.

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Venture Rabbit Meal & Pumpkin

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Venture Rabbit Meal & Pumpkin - Sheriff Score
Sheriff Score D+
Nutrients and value
Protein content: 🟠 26%
Fat content: 🟢 13%
Ash content: Unknown
Fiber content: 🟢 6%
Moisture content: 🟢 10%
Calcium content: Unknown
Phosphorus content: Unknown
Metabolizable energy: 3500 kcal/kg
Omega-3 content: 1%
Omega-6 content: 3.4%
Carbohydrate content: 🔴 35%
Protein-to-calorie ratio: 74
Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio: Unknown
Animal protein content: 🟠 60-70%
High glycemic index ingredients: 🟢 None
Corn/wheat/soy content: 🟢 No
Chelated minerals: 🟠 Mix

Rabbit meal leads this formula, which is actually encouraging as it delivers concentrated protein since the moisture’s been removed during processing. You’re getting more actual protein per pound compared to fresh meat that’s mostly water. The 26% protein level sits in reasonable territory, though it’s still shy of the 30% sweet spot for active dogs. At 35% carbohydrates, this formula leans toward the upper end of what’s common in commercial kibble, though it doesn’t venture into extreme territory.

What’s more concerning is the lack of transparency: we don’t know the calcium or phosphorus content, nor the crude ash level (other recipes too, except the weight loss recipe). These aren’t trivial omissions. The calcium-phosphorus ratio is critical for bone health and muscular function, especially in growing or senior dogs, and excessive ash can point to low-grade mineral content or poor-quality meat meals.

Without this data, it’s impossible to fully assess the formula’s nutritional soundness or bioavailability.

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Great Plains Feast

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Great Plains Feast - Sheriff Score
Sheriff Score D+
Nutrients and value
Protein content: 🟢 32%
Fat content: 🟢 18%
Ash content: Unknown
Fiber content: 🟢 5%
Moisture content: 🟢 10%
Calcium content: Unknown
Phosphorus content: Unknown
Metabolizable energy: 3650 kcal/kg
Omega-3 content: 1.9%
Omega-6 content: 3%
Carbohydrate content: 🟢 25%
Protein-to-calorie ratio: 88
Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio: Unknown
Animal protein content: 🟠 40-60%
High glycemic index ingredients: 🟢 None
Corn/wheat/soy content: 🟢 No
Chelated minerals: 🟠 Mix

Finally, a formula that doesn’t skimp on protein! 32% gets us into proper territory for active dogs. Bison meal offers something different for pups with chicken or beef sensitivities. Multiple fish sources pump up those omega-3s, and research shows the omega balance really does affect how your dog’s body handles inflammation. But here’s the catch – pea protein still crashes the party in third position, artificially boosting those protein numbers. Added to that, all the usual flaws of the recipes.

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Weight Control

EARTHBORN HOLISTIC Weight Control - sheriff score
sheriff score C
Nutrients and value
Protein content: 🟠 25%
Fat content: 🔴 7%
Ash content: Unknown
Fiber content: 🟠 9%
Moisture content: 🟢 10%
Calcium content: 🟢 1.1%
Phosphorus content: 🟢 0.8%
Metabolizable energy: 3090 kcal/kg
Omega-3 content: Unknown
Omega-6 content: Unknown
Carbohydrate content: 🔴 39%
Protein-to-calorie ratio: 81
Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio: 🟢 1.38
Animal protein content: 🟠 40-60%
High glycemic index ingredients: 🟢 None
Corn/wheat/soy content: 🟢 No
Chelated minerals: 🟠 Mix

A weight management formula with 39% carbs? It goes against recent scientific findings. A 2024 study published in Animals compared two commercial weight-loss diets for dogs: one high in protein (34.2%) and low in carbs (27.3%), the other high in fiber and carbohydrates (44%).

The results were clear: dogs on the higher-protein, lower-carb diet lost more fat, maintained more muscle, and their owners reported a better quality of life: less hunger, better energy, and improved behavior.

So while this formula’s 7% fat and added L-Carnitine do align with standard weight-loss strategies, the carb-heavy composition undermines its goal. This is a common approach in commercial weight management kibbles, manufacturers often focus on cutting fat, which is calorie-dense, while filling in the gaps with cheaper carbohydrates.

This time, however, we do have the calcium and phosphorus levels. The calcium-phosphorus ratio (1.38:1) is well-calibrated.

Our Opinion

Here’s what stands out after digging into these formulas: Earthborn plays it safe, maybe too safe. Most recipes hover around 24-26% protein when your dog really needs 30%+ to thrive. That’s not terrible, but it’s not great either.

Great Plains Feast stands as their best effort – decent protein, reasonable carbs, interesting protein sources. The rest of the line feels like they’re following industry formulas rather than pushing boundaries for better canine nutrition.

On the positive side : clean ingredient lists, natural preservatives, and solid omega fatty acid profiles. No sketchy chemicals or mystery meat here. The rabbit and bison options offer something different for picky eaters or dogs with sensitivities.

But, they’re stuck in that middle ground like NutriSource or Edgard & Cooper. It’s still better than basic commercial formulas, but not quite hitting premium nutritional targets. If you’re feeding Earthborn now, your dog’s probably doing fine. But if you’re shopping around, there are formulas out there that hit protein targets without the carb overload. For more info, check our best dry food for dogs.

⚠️ Important : Remember, every dog is unique. What works for one may not work for another. This analysis is a tool, not a prescription. Always consult your veterinarian when making dietary decisions for your pet.
 About the author