Black Gold Dog Food Review (Dry)

Black and Gold is a US-based dog food brand that has been around for over 20 years. Their product line includes formulas designed for puppies, adult dogs, sensitive dogs, large breeds, and even those with special energy needs, such as working or senior dogs. Let’s explore the various recipes to assess the strengths and weaknesses of this long-standing brand.

Black and Gold Dog Dry Food Review Ratings

Here’s our analysis of this brand recipes.

Black and Gold Original Performance Formula

33/100

Although the macronutrient ratios are appealing, the presence of gluten sources, corn, and high glycemic index ingredients could reduce the overall quality and may pose concerns for dogs prone to food sensitivities or weight issues.

Black and Gold Super Performance Formula

49/100

A variety of kibble designed for dogs with high energy needs. The absence of gluten, corn, and high glycemic index ingredients, combined with reasonable macronutrient levels, boosts the Sheriff Score. However, the brand’s previously mentioned drawbacks prevent the score from rising further.

Black and Gold Puppy Recipe

50/100

As is often the case, puppy formulas tend to be the best formulated in pet food brands. With an adequate protein level, increased fat content to meet the energy needs of growing puppies, and excellent energy density, this recipe stands out from the others of the brand.

Black and Gold Large Breed Puppy Recipe

46/100

Nothing new here, but both the protein and fat levels are lower, allowing for a higher carbohydrate content. Carbohydrates take up more space in the formula.

Black and Gold Beef Meal & Barley Recipe

35/100

A recipe that leaves too much room for carbohydrates, especially high glycemic index ones. The protein and fat levels may not be adequate for all dogs, potentially making this formula less ideal for those needing more balanced macronutrients.

Black and Gold Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Recipe

41/100

The same thing, but at least there’s no soy, wheat, or corn.

Black and Gold Sensitive Skin & Coat Ocean Fish Meal & Oat Recipe

41/100

A recipe designed for sensitive dogs. As is often the case with these formulas, the protein levels are unfortunately quite low. Additionally, the inclusion of chicken is a drawback, as it is a common allergen for dogs with protein allergies.

Black and Gold Large Breed Adult Recipe

47/100

The carbohydrate content reaches a record high for this Black and Gold : 52%. Most of the carbohydrate sources come from whole grains, but it’s still a bit excessive. The protein level is low, and the fat content has also been reduced.

Black and Gold Mature 7+ Recipe

41/100

Senior dogs need high-quality proteins, not necessarily fewer proteins. It would also be preferable if the phosphorus levels were reduced and the mineral content was clearly specified.

Our Opinion

Overall, Black and Gold provides a range of dog food formulas targeting different life stages and needs, but significant issues limit its overall quality. While some recipes offer balanced macronutrients and avoid problematic ingredients like gluten, soy, and corn, the brand faces drawbacks. A consistent issue is the high carbohydrate content, with some recipes reaching up to 52%, which is excessive for most dogs and may lead to weight gain and blood sugar spikes. The heavy reliance on plant-based proteins, lack of transparency in key nutritional data, and nutrient levels being listed as minimums add to the uncertainty. Without evidence of professional formulation or backtested scientific validation, these weaknesses overshadow the brand’s potential.

Please note that the Sheriff Score could potentially be higher if more nutritional information and details about the processing methods were available.